Thursday, August 26, 2010
Conference on Free Software and Education
Now it seems this is going to come true. When I suggested this idea, there was positive response from the Boards of FSF India and SPACE. The response from Prof. Mohandas of the National Institute of Technology, Calicut, (NITC) also was positive. So we planned to do this as part of the Golden Jubilee celebrations of NITC, which starts in October. But then Richard Stallman decided to come to India, and NITC was interested in him coming for the conference. So we had to advance the programme to September beginning. Stallman had to leave India on 12th, so the conference had to be before that. And Prof. Mohandas suggested 11th and 12th, with the inauguration on 10th evening. And RMS agreed. So the conference will happen on those days.
The response from speakers also was good. Prof. Nagarjuna (Homi Bhabha Centre for Science Education), Chairperson of FSF India, immediately agreed to speak. And FSF India decided to become one of the organisers. Prof. Kannan Moudgalya and Prabhu Ramachandran of IIT, Mumbai, also were enthusiastic. Prof. K.R. Srivathsan (PVC, IGNOU) eagerly agreed to speak. And my good friend Juan Carlos Gentile decided to make it an international affair. He has found several speakers from abroad, including Marco Ciurcina from Italy and Diego Saravia from Argentina, and they all will speak through video netowrking. He is also arranging for live webcasting. And all of them and many others are willing to endorse the call the conference will make to use Free Software in education.
In short, this conference is becoming a much bigger affair than I ever imagined. My only regret is that the Chief Minister of Kerala, who is a great supporter of Free Software and normally makes it a point to participate in any meeting in which RMS is present, will not be available to inaugurate the conference. It is good that he has agreed to send a video message. I hope there will be good participation from different parts of the country. And that this will give a boost to migration in educational institutions in the country and to substituting proprietary software in university curricula with Free Software.
Tuesday, June 15, 2010
മലയാള മനോരമയുടെ കസര്ത്തു്
ഒരര്ത്ഥത്തില് ഈ വാര്ത്ത വലിയ ദോഷം ചെയ്യുന്ന ഒന്നല്ല. കാരണം സാമാന്യ ബുദ്ധിയുള്ള ഒരാള്ക്കു് അതിലടങ്ങിയിരിക്കുന്ന മറ്റുതാല്പര്യങ്ങള് കാണാന് കഴിഞ്ഞു എന്നു വരാം. പണം നഷ്ടപ്പെടാന് പോകുന്നു എന്നു് പറഞ്ഞതു് ആരാണു് എന്നു് അവര് വ്യക്തമാക്കിയിട്ടില്ല. പണം തരുന്നതു് കേന്ദ്രസര്ക്കാര് ആയതുകൊണ്ടു് സംസ്ഥാന സര്ക്കാരിന്റെ നയങ്ങളൊന്നും പാലിക്കേണ്ടതില്ല എന്നു് അര്ത്ഥം വരുന്നില്ല. സ്വതന്ത്ര സോഫ്റ്റ്വെയറുപയോഗിച്ചു് ഇങ്ങനത്തെ ആവശ്യങ്ങള്ക്കുള്ള സോഫ്റ്റ്വെയറുകള് നിര്മ്മിക്കാനാവില്ല എന്നു് ഒരു വിദഗ്ദ്ധന്റെയും വാക്കുകള് ഉദ്ധരിച്ചു് സ്ഥാപിക്കാന് ശ്രമിച്ചിട്ടില്ല. അതു് ലേഖകന്റെ അഭിപ്രായമായാണു് മനോരമയുടെ സൈറ്റില് കാണുന്നതു്. ലേഖകന് സോഫ്റ്റ്വെയര് വിദഗ്ദ്ധനാണെന്ന സൂചന പോലുമില്ല. മാത്രമല്ല, ഏറ്റവും കുറഞ്ഞ ടെന്ഡര് നല്കിയ കമ്പനിക്കു് സോഫ്റ്റ്വെയര് നിര്മ്മിക്കാനുള്ള പണി നല്കി എന്നൊരു വിചിത്രമായ ആരോപണവും ഉന്നയിച്ചിരിക്കുന്നു. ഇതിന്റെയെല്ലാം പിന്നില് മറ്റെന്തോ ഉണ്ടായിരിക്കണമെന്നു തോന്നിക്കാന് ഇനിയൊന്നും വേണ്ടല്ലോ.
ഒരു കുട്ടിക്കു് ഒരു ലാപ്ടോപ്പ് (One Laptop Per Child, OLPC) എന്ന സംരംഭത്തിനുവേണ്ടി തയാറാക്കിയ XO എന്ന ലാപ്ടോപ്പ് മുതല് സൂപ്പര് കമ്പ്യൂട്ടറുകള് വരെ സ്വതന്ത്ര സോഫ്റ്റ്വെയറായ ഗ്നു ലിനക്സ് ഉപയോഗിച്ചു് പ്രവര്ത്തിക്കുന്നു. ഇന്റര്നെറ്റ് ഉപയോക്താക്കള്ക്കു് ഏറ്റവും പ്രിയംകരമായ സെര്ച്ച് എഞ്ചിനായ ഗൂഗിളിന്റെ സെര്വ്വറുകളില് ഉപയോഗിക്കുന്നതു് സ്വതന്ത്ര സോഫ്റ്റ്വെയറായ ഗ്നു ലിനക്സാണു്. രണ്ടാം സ്ഥാനത്തു് നില്ക്കുന്നു എന്നു പറയാവുന്ന യാഹുവിന്റെ സെര്വ്വറുകളെല്ലാം മറ്റൊരു സ്വതന്ത്ര സോഫ്റ്റ്വെയറായ Free BSDയിലാണു് പ്രവര്ത്തിക്കുന്നതു്. നമ്മുടെ LICയുടെ കമ്പ്യൂട്ടര് ശൃംഘല പ്രവര്ത്തിക്കുന്നതു് ഗ്നു ലിനക്സിലാണു്. അതുപോലെ തന്നെ ജര്മ്മനിയിലെ മ്യൂണിക്ക് നഗരസഭയുടെ കമ്പ്യൂട്ടറുകളും. പിന്നെയാണോ വൈദ്യുത ബോര്ഡിന്റെ ബില്ലിംഗ് നടത്താനുള്ള സോഫ്റ്റ്വെയര് സ്വതന്ത്ര സോഫ്റ്റ്വെയറുപയോഗിച്ചു് സാധ്യമല്ലാതെ വരുന്നതു്!
ഇത്രയേറെ പ്രചാരവും പഴക്കവുമുള്ള ഒരു പത്രം ഇത്രയും തരം താഴുന്നതു് കഷ്ടമാണു്. അവര്ക്കു് അതില്നിന്നു് എന്തു നേട്ടമാണോ ഉണ്ടാകുമെന്നു് പ്രതീക്ഷിക്കുന്നതു്, ഇത്ര മോശമായ പത്രപ്രവര്ത്തനത്തിലൂടെ അതിനേക്കാള് കൂടുതല് നഷ്ടമേ അവര്ക്കു് ഉണ്ടാകാനിടയുള്ളൂ. കയ്യില് കിട്ടുന്നതെന്തും ഉപയോഗിച്ചു് സര്ക്കാരിനെ അടിക്കാന് ശ്രമിക്കുന്നതു് മനസിലാക്കാം, അംഗീകരിക്കാനാവില്ലെങ്കിലും. പക്ഷെ വടിയല്ല ചാണകമാണു് കയ്യില് കിട്ടിയതു് എന്നു് മനസിലാക്കിയില്ലെങ്കില് സ്വന്തം ശരീരമെ വൃത്തികേടാകൂ. സര് സി.പി. രാമസ്വാമി അയ്യരെ എതിര്ത്തു് ജയിലില് പോയ ചരിത്രമുള്ള മലയാള മനോരമ ഇങ്ങനെ അധഃപതിക്കുന്നതു് കാണുമ്പോള് ദുഃഖമേ വരൂ.
Friday, May 28, 2010
Chau to Latin America
I met a small child there wearing a T shirt that said GNU/Linux. He became friendly to me and we sat on the floor of the dias talking for some time - he in Spanish and I in Malayalam, just as i used to do with the third child of Charles. But this time Quiliro was there to do a bit of interpretation for me. I met the family as I came out of the building and they had taken a few photographs with me carrying the child. I did request them to send me the photos, but I have not yet received them. I shall put them up here as soon as I get them.
From the University, all of us went to the airport. Rafael, his brother-in-law, Quiliro and others were there to see us off, and we soon left Ecuador on a TACA flight. The airport had free wifi access and Juan and I made use of the opportunity to check our mails. I just sent a mail to Lucho saying that we were leaving. Since the flight was in the evening, and it became dark soon, there was nothing interesting to see and the wait at Lima also was normal. We reached Asuncion early in the morning and Lucho and his girl friend were there waiting for us at 3 in the morning. We went straight to his house and soon were asleep. Before I went to sleep, I just sent a mail to my brother-in-law in Dubai, Ajith Kumar, saying that I was back in Asuncion and would try to get the flight from Dubai postponed by a few days.
The next morning, we went to the travel agency that, as Juan found out, had booked my tickets and got the flight from Dubai to Delhi postponed by a few days. It cost me US $ 150, which, I thought, was a bit high. Later, it turned out that I could buy a new ticket from Dubai to Kerala for a similar amount. That would have saved me the fare from Delhi to Thiruvananthapuram. Anyway, the money was spent and there was nothing I could do about it. From the travel agency, we had to go quickly back to Lucho's home because he was called to sort out some problem in some system that he was looking after. So he left us home and quickly went out. And I started wondering how I would go to the airport. Juan told me that Nicolas (Pereira) would come to drop me to the airport.
My flight was supposed to be at 6 pm and I should be at the airport by 3 pm. The drive to the airport was supposed to be about 30-40 minutes. So I was expecting Nicolas to reach by about 2:15 pm. When there was no sign of Nicolas, Juan called him. Nicolas said that he was in a meeting and would reach in ten minutes. He also said that he knows someone in the airlines, so there will not be any problem. Finally, both Nicolases came and we all went to the airport. On the way, Nicolas Caballero said that there were two pieces of good news. One was that the electricity company had offered US $ 100,000 every year to conduct a Free Software conference. That was good news indeed! I asked him how much that would be, in real terms, in Paraguay. Nicolas said that the Free Software Asuncion conference for which I had originally gone there, had cost only about US$ 55,000. Then I asked him whether they could keep apart some money for starting an institute for Free Software. Nicolas responded by saying that that was the second good news. The same company had offered a million US dollars to start such a Centre! That was absolutely great!
We must have reached the airport around 4:30 pm and I had no problem in checking in. They allowed my small suitcase and my laptop bag to be taken in the cabin so that I wouldn't have to wait for the baggage in Dubai. The only problem was that I had to cart it around in Sao Paulo. I did not have to pay airport taxes because that was included in the ticket. So we finally said good bye and Nicolas said that we should meet again. I suggested that he organise a Free Software conference in Canada (where he was moving to in a couple of months). They had to go in a hurry because they had a meeting at 5 pm, and I walked in. I had about an hour to wait before the flight took off, which I spent mostly reading Freakonomics. Soon we were ushered into a Boeing 747 which took off as scheduled. And that was chau to Asuncion and Latin America.
Sunday, May 09, 2010
Quito, Ecuador
We were taken to the airport by Lucho and Claudia (Lucho's wife) and seen off at 5:30 in the morning because the flight was at 7 pm. The flight was via Lima, Peru, where we had about an hour to spend. We arrived in Quito in the early afternoon and Charles was waiting for us. We were taken to his house (he drives a Lada car, the first one I have seen) where I slept for some time after food. We then went straight to Charles' place of work, the Israel University. From there, Juan and I were taken to the office of the National Union of School teachers, where they asked about the Kerala experience in using Free Software in education. They said that IT was not part of the education system and that the government was not giving much priority to education. They also said that they had had a detailed discussion about constructivism in education and decided that Vygotsky's system was better (they said "Levgotsky" but I guess they must have meant Vygotsky). They were interested to know how the system was implemented in Kerala and I told them that it may be possible to arrange for a discussion. I met Tatyana here, who translated my words into Spanish and what the others said in Spanish to me in English. And she did a very good job. One of the teachers there did video interviews with me and Juan for their website.
Quiliro Ordóñez from Ecuador had written to me and Juan asking about when we can meet, and we met him in the evening on our way back from the University. We had some food from a restaurant where I ate something that was like idli but slightly sweet and steamed or baked in a banana leaf. Another thing was wrapped in corn leaf (again steamed or baked) that came with a kind of chutney containing onion and chillies. This was the first time I was eating something spicy after coming to Latin America and it felt nice. But as a result we reached home very late and I was too tired to even try to log into the Internet.
Charles said that we had to leave early morning the next day (May 6th) because vehicles with registration numbers ending with a particular digit are banned on every day and this day he could not take his car into the city after 7 am. So we had to leave at about 6 pm. We went straight to Charles' office and from there we went with one of his students, Danillo Rojas, to a radio station for a discussion on Free Software. The radio station is run by a Socialist member of the National Assembly. His name is Paco Velasco and he is a supporter of Free Software. He himself anchored the show and he turned out to be a very bubbly character in the show (or, as Juan said, a very "electric" character). He was supported by another person who, I think, was the regular anchor for the programme. The show went on for one hour and four or five people called in, all of them supporting Free Software. Later, the Free Software activists here and Juan got several mails from people who had listened to the radio programme. It was a good success in that sense.
From the radio station we went to the Israel University where we had a short break with coffee and some snacks. And what was there in the plate of snacks? Surprise! Banana chips with onions and tomato! A very pleasant surprise indeed! We then went to an auditorium in the building where I gave a brief talk on Free Software for scientific data analysis and visualisation. It had to be very brief because we had to quickly go to the Army Polytechnic. This was a really interesting experience. Col. Sanchez, who was in charge of the Department of Electronics and Communication, invited us to give a seminar on the use of Free Software. Tatyana was with us and we learned that she worked in the institute. She was the person who took us around and organised the seminar. The hall was full and there were students standing. I again started with a Kathakali video and pictures of different parts of Kerala. Then I went on to explain how Kerala had migrated to Free Software and why only Free Software should be used in education and in the government. I said that Juan will explain the reason and what happened in Venezuela. Tatyana did a very good job of translating my speech once again. By the time Juan finished his speech, the conference had already been going on for about two hours and people were still standing. At one point of time, I had to mention about how the media is now very alert about the use of non-free software and how on a couple of occasions it made a noise when there were attempts to use non-free software. I was surprised by the big applause that followed.
Then they had a short coffee break and reassembled for the talk by Rafael. I thought most of the people would leave, but most of the audience was still there when Rafael started! This extent of interest apparently surprised even the faculty and authorities of the polytechnic because apparently no one used to sit for more than half an hour! Rafael spoke about the Elastix distribution for which he is working and explained how one can make a living out of working for Free Software. We were free for what remained of the day. Mario Albuja, who was there, invited us (Juan, Tatyana and me) to dinner and we went up the hill to a place that gave us a good view of the city. It was beautiful with all the lights. I talked about doing some studies about the schools, like the one I proposed in Paraguay, and they said that we can do. I hope it really happens.
On May 7th, we again went to the radio station, but I was there only for less than half an hour. I had to then go to a school where Quiliro had arranged a talk with a few teachers and students. I started with an introduction to Kerala and went on to speak about why Free Software should be used in schools. I started by asking what they would do if they got a packet of sweets. They said they would share it with everyone, and then I went on to the question about software. It turned out that neither the teachers nor the students used legal versions of Windows, and hence they were largely unaware of the legal issues related to copying proprietary software. Teachers were asking about Kerala, and how the state is different from the rest of India. A teacher asked me about what kind of software is used for teaching. I showed them things like Kalzium, Stellarium and Gcompris, and I think the students and the teachers were really excited. But Rafael Bonifaz was there soon telling me that we needed to go to some other place. I had to leave the place with the teachers and students apparently wanting to know more. I hope the local community would keep in touch with them.
The place we went to was the office of the Telecommunications Minister, Jaime Guerrero. He looked like a traditional Britisher, with a very impressive bearing. It was Juan who spoke most of the time. But the minister seemed to be impressed and we got to take a photograph with him. I did not understand what the Minister of Telecommunication had to do with Free Software, especially because we were talking mostly about education. I was told later that it was this ministry that supplied computers to the schools. I hope the minister was convinced about the need to give computers with Free Software to the schools, but I am not sure whether someone is going to give training in using the computers.
The next stop was at the office of the National Electoral Council. The head of the council (Director?) was present and there also I spoke about the importance of using Free Software especially for critical applications in the government. Juan spoke about the experience of Venezuela. The Director asked whether there were applications for specialised purposes like GIS and I explained about GRASS. But I did mention that there could be some specific areas where Free Software is not yet available. There were questions about Kerala and how the state had decided to migrate to Free Software. The impression we got when we left was that the doubts they had about using Free Software was largely removed.
Next we went to the Ministry of Education, where we met a small team who apparently are in charge of education. They consisted of teachers and technologists. We spoke about why Free Software is important for education and how Kerala migrated to Free Software. The interest in Free Software seemed to be low. They were saying that the country does not even have computers in all schools and that the major problem they were facing was in creating content. I said that I did not think textual and picture content in digital format was not the most important thing, and that the full potential of the digital technology could be exploited only with applications that allowed children to explore specific subjects or topics. One teacher asked what was the advantage of using Free Software other than the cost. I explained how we had localised GNU/Linux and how Windows was still not giving a desktop with Malayalam. But, apparently, they were not very much enthused. As we moved out of the hall where the meeting was conducted, a TV crew was waiting for an interview. They asked a few questions to me and a few to Juan. I don't remember exactly what they asked.
We then rushed to the Secretariat for Informatics which is headed by Mario. They had apparently been waiting for some time and they had food ready for us. They did a presentation about what they are doing to introduce Free Software in the government. They said that most of the servers were running Free Software, including some of the critical applications. Mario seemed to be taking pains to show us that they were really promoting Free Software in the government. But, apparently, many desktops were still running Windows. Since the discussion was mostly in English, I did not need an interpreter. Where needed, Juan did the job.
Our next stop was at the organisation in charge of "intellectual property" laws. The person in charge (Director?) explained that their stand was that IP laws were needed, and they had a positive role to play, but the legal system often distorted the laws to the advantage of companies and the disadvantage of the public. He said that they were working to make the IP laws more friendly to the consumers. Juan told him that IP laws should vanish, but the Director said that he believes that IP laws do help creators, and that it would be wonderful if people published their creative works under Free licences, but those who did not want to do so should have the freedom to do as they wished. I asked him about patents and the patenting of traditional knowledge. He said that other countries are taking traditional knowledge from here and the country was trying to get paid for it. And I replied that, as far as I was concerned, anyone was free to take the knowledge and use it but they cannot try to control the knowledge through patents or other such things. Juan and the Director agreed to disagree, but my stand was somewhere in the middle, though I never said so. I didn't need an interpreter here because the Director spoke good English.
We then went to Charles' institute, from where all of us (Charles, Juan, Quiliro and I) went to CIEEPI, which is an association of electrical and electronic engineers of Pichincha. Esteban also joined us at the University. The institute had arranged some food for us, which consisted of a salad. But I was not in a mood to eat cold food, and I did not eat. The discussions were mostly in Spanish with Juan speaking from our side. It appeared that they were interested in some kind of tie up with SPACE, but it was not clear to me what they were looking for. After the meeting, Charles, Juan, Esteban, Quiliro and I left for home. But then Quiliro suggested that we go to an old part of the city. We went to the top of a small peak Panecilo where there is a monument with a huge statue of Virgin Mary with wings looking at the city below. It was apparently built in Europe and transported here in pieces. The construction is said to have taken one hundred years, though it was installed only in the late 1990s. The place had several small shops selling curios, all of them run by natives. Some of the things were very intersting, but I didn't have any money to buy anything. Charles bought a keyring for me, which has a small leather thing attached to it. We also ate something that consisted of a cooked ear of corn with cheese. We also had a traditional drink which was available in two forms, with and without alcohol. I had the one without alcohol and it was sweet and nice. The television was showing a programme, interestingly, about India.
From there we went to an old part of the city with narrow streets and finally to a square with the President's palace on one side, an ancient cathedral on the second, a very old building that now houses the Majestic Hotel on the third and a new building housing the Municipal office on the fourth side. In the centre was a monument to the memory of the people who were killed during the war of independence with the Spanish. Apparently, half the population was killed by the Spanish and the leaders imprisoned. The local Spanish leaders needed permission from the Spanish government to kill the leaders. So the leaders were kept in prison for a year and then killed. The old buildings were really majestic, including the cathedral, and a sharp contrast to the monotonous modern buildings we see everywhere else. It was a real experience to be at a historic site where the first declaration of independence was signed in the Americas. Ecuador is, therefore, known as the Light of America for this reason. It was a fine end to a rather busy day and, as we returned, my mind was full of the sacrifice of thousands of people for the freedom of their countrymen and the cruelty that imperialist regimes meted out to them, including what the British did in India.
Saturday, May 01, 2010
OLPC, School for the Disabled and Interviews
They talked about promoting OLPC here and evolving methods of using the machine to teach. They were also talking about Free hardware. As the discussions dragged on, it was getting to be time for lunch and all of us went to a restaurant. But we were supposed to go for a meeting on MMSL (the organisation that conducted the conference) at 2 pm and we quickly left, with the OLPC guys still enjoying their food. On the way, Juan and Lucho expressed their displeasure with the group because they appeared to be first world guys approaching the problem with a typical first world approach. Juan thought they were kind of undesirable and Lucho seemed to agree. Juan said that if this was how OLPC was being promoted here, we needed to push for another computer taking its place.
At the venue of the MMSL meeting, we found Nicolas (Cabellero and Pereira) and a new person who was to be the Director of Free Software for the Ministry of Education, Oswaldo Daniel Cruz Ramirez. Later, Gladys Canese, the President of MMSL, joined us. Nicolas Caballero introduced us to Oswaldo, who would be one of the people who would be coming to Kerala. He outlined the ideas the Ministry is pursuing and left us to discuss things with Oswaldo. Before a serious discussion could happen, Nicolas left us because he had some important and urgent work to finish. While we were discussing Oswaldo coming to Kerala and how he can prepare himself for the visit, Nicolas came again to introduce a journalist who had come to interview me.
The journalist, who turned out to be from Uruguay (Juan's country) was fluent with only Spanish and Juan had to interpret. There is nothing much to write about the interview because he asked only the usual questions and we all thought that he did a poor interview. After he left, I sat with Oswaldo and talked a few things about what he can read to prepare himself for coming to Kerala. I gave him my card and told him to send me a mail so that I could send him some links that would be useful. Nicolas and others were going to the Congress to present a proposal for digital television that can also help in education, and invited us to join. I declined though Juan was inclined to go, and we all came back home.
At home, I lay down and fell asleep. I was woken up by noises and was told that there were a couple of journalists to interview me for an online newspaper. The guy could speak good English, so it was much easier. He asked me a couple of good questions apart from the routine ones. He asked me whether I though that Free Software would become popular when there were so many proprietary software companies opposing it. I said that I was sure that it was only a question of time before Free Software becomes ubiquitous and he asked me how long I expected that to take. I said, I think, that I could not be sure but it may take maybe two years, maybe five. It was a short interview and he said that it would be published in about two or three days. I felt nervous after the interview because I had been asleep and was afraid that I might have said something that I should not have. But Juan said that I handled it well, and that the man was from a far right newspaper. In such interviews, I am always afraid that they may distort what I say and highlight something that was totally unintended. Hope that doesn't happen.
Today (May 1) we were mostly lazing around but for a visit to a school that teaches children with disabilities along with normal children. We were received by an elderly lady who was, as she said, working with a government school. She decided to start such a school after she retired. She said that she started with children with Down's syndrome but now had no such children in the school. They apparently had children with Dyslexia, Autism and physical handicaps. She said that she had got training for handling such children and she was the first to introduce inclusive education. All over the country, children with such challenges were taught separately. She showed some photographs of children apparently celebrating, but I couldn't see any physically disabled child in them. We couldn't see any special gadgets (wheel chairs, etc) for children with disabilities either. We also met her son and another young person who said they were involved in training and development in Mechatronics. Though I thought that the lady was doing very good work, later we had doubts whether they were really speaking the truth. I suggested that Lucho go there on a working day, if possible, and find out whether there really were physically or mentally challenged children there. I had talked to her about the school in Kolkata where such children were taught along with others, the only such school in India and she wanted to get in touch with them. I promised to send them the contact details. Later, Juan said that they were also apparently looking for money. That made me wonder what their intentions were. But Juan said that we will try to do something for them. I left it at that, hoping that Lucho will go there one day and see what exactly is happening.
The rest of the day was mostly idling and I slept a lot.
Wednesday, April 28, 2010
Visits to the National University of Asuncion
I said that law tells us what to do and what not to do, while technology decided how we do things. In that sense, the two are related. Therefore, I argued, law should be compatible to technology. I spoke about how the copyright law came into being and how the rights of the authors were extended to ridiculous periods (60 years after the death of the author), becoming a stumbling block for creativity. I then talked about showed how the copyright law was inhibiting the sharing of knowledge when technology existed that made it possible for any music or book to be transmitted to any number of people around the globe in an instant. I also spoke about how the Recording Industry Association of America objected to the tape recorder technology and continues to object to people sharing music and movies although music sharing had not brought any harm to the industry. There were questions on why people should not get money by selling music and withholding free downloads. Juan explained the matter and at the end apparently everyone agreed on the idea of Free Knowledge. There were some students who stayed back after the talk and talked to us (Lucho, Juan and me). A couple of students told me that they are familiar with the Indian culture and like it very much. I had showed them a video of Kathakali and another of Thrissur pooram (and a dozen images of Kerala) and this is what prompted them to tell me about the Indian culture.
Yesterday was a rather busy day. We went to a local school here, in a poor neighbourhood. I will write about it elsewhere. At 2 pm, we went to the IT department of the National University, which is in a different campus. This was a large and beautiful campus with lots of trees and beautiful buildings with exposed brick. Here, the talk was organised by a faculty member, who seemed to be favouring Free Software. The students slowly trickled in and ultimately we had something like fifty students. I again started with the videos and images from Kerala and that seems to have caught their imagination. The talk was on Technology and Society and I started with why we develop technolgy and for whom. There was one student who was quite knowledgeable about these things and supported Free Software. He was making the right responses whenever I raised questions. I started with how technology changes the way we do things and the kind of benefits that society gets. I then brought the discussion to how businesses tried to block the benefits people can get from technology, mentioning the effort of RIAA to ban the tape recorder technology. I pointed out that it is stupid to attempt to block technological development based on arguments about how the new technology can harm the existing systems because every advance in technology has harmed the existing system. For example, I mentioned how computers had led to painters of sign boards losing their jobs. Interestingly, there were questions about the social and political system in Kerala and how Free software development was funded in Kerala. There were, of course, also questions about how programmers will live if they gave away the code they write as Free Software. With help from Juan, I explained why software is like poetry or any other creative work and we don't need people to earn their livelihood writing software for general use. One thing I forgot to mention was that most software developers live by writing custom software, which need not be Free Software at all because it is to be used only by a limited number of people.
Here also there were people discussing with us after the talk but we needed to move again. Before that, we were invited to the office of one of the faculty members, which was the incubation centre for businesses. They were working with an enterprise based on Free Software and were wondering about some kind of collaboration with SPACE. We spent a very pleasant time there before we moved to the next meeting.
The last meeting of the day was in the Sociology department of the same University, which was in another building in the city. This building was apparently the house of a very wealthy person and looked like an old palace. This time we had a class full of students and a few faculty members, and there was the Director of the faculty, an elderly gentleman who told me that he had come to India on a few occasions. He sat for quite some time before he excused himself. But he spoke to the audience before he left and apparently told them about the importance of the topic, and that soon people who are computer illiterate would be considered to be similar to people who could not read or write. I started with the concept of alienation of the worker from work and how technology impacts society. I then moved to ICT and how it is influencing the way we do things. I told them about Free Software and how this idea of freedom is beginning to create a revolution in the way we think and do things. I told them that this movement has led to freedom movements in other sectors, like Wikipedia, and also debunked the idea that people will do things only if they get some benefit out of it. I told them about how the law is preventing the full potential of the technology from reaching society. I also told them that, as Sociologists, it was their duty to study the changes happening in society and how effectively the technology was reaching people. I also told them that Kerala had adopted Free Software for all public applications, and particularly for school education. Interestingly, there were questions about the political and social situation in Keala and whether other states in India were similar. Discussions after the talk went for a long time and I was happy to see that so many students were enthused by the idea.
We returned very much satisfied with the day's efforts, though rather exhausted.
Monday, April 26, 2010
Free Software Asuncion 2010
I reached the conference venue only at night on the first day of the conference, and so missed half the presentations. The second day morning, I was initially told that my talk would be at 1 pm. But then, the person in charge of organising, Nicolas Cabellera, came and told me that a person who was supposed to do a workshop on Python had withdrawn at the last minute. He thought this was a kind of attempt to sabotage the conference. He asked me whether I would use that time. I said that I could do a workshop on LaTeX, something that Juan Carlos had told me I would have to do here. And he was extremely happy that I saved the day for them!
I finished just a simple introduction to LaTeX in the given time, and I found that it was helpful to a few people -- in fact they came and said so to me. I had little time to have my lunch and get my presentation ready. But when I was ready, I was told that there were a couple of presentations before mine. A young person (forgot his name) spoke about some work they are doing with discarded hardware. There was one more presentation before I was told that next will be mine. But before that, about twenty chairs were arranged in front of the audience, and people like Charles Escobar, Diego Saravia, Nicolas Cabellero, Juan Carlos, Marco Cuircina, and others, including me, were asked to sit there. Then Diego Saravia spoke about the confusion of several distributions and sometimes code getting written for specific distributions (which is not what Free Software is about). Since all talks were in Spanish, and most people followed only Spanish, I was provided with an interpreter who helped me understand the gist of the speeches, and also interpreted my talk. He turned out to be a n interesting guy and we got along very well. Being a professional interpreter, he had come to me in the morning, and we had sat together and gone through my presentation so that he won't be surprised by some words.
I started my presentation with two videos, one of Kathakali and another of Thrissur Pooram. This was followed by about a dozen pictures of Kerala. I then presented some statistics about Kerala, comparing it with Paraguay, such as area, population, density of population and literacy. I then went through a brief introduction to the geography and history of Kerala, focussing on social and political reforms. Only after this did I start talking about IT@School. After explaining how it started and IT was introduced as part of the curriculum, I explained how they were pressured into migrating to Free Software, and now were moving to IT Enabled Education.
I ended my presentation with questions about why many of these things happened in Kerala, and not in any other state. I pointed out that it has no easy answer, but probably was due to its geographical isolation and so many historical reasons. I tried to explain that it is not possible to simply copy a process that was successful in one part of the world and expect it to be equally successful in another part. There were just a few questions at the end, but nothing really interesting. Overall, I thought I could have spoken better. I think I was hampered by the fact that I was still under the influence of the tiring journey that lasted about 28 hours and also under jet lag. Moreover, I think, the fact that the people could not follow English well, and therefore their responses came only after the interpreter explained in Spanish what I had said, also might have affected my speech. Anyway, I am happy that several people appreciated my presentation.
Here are some photographs from the event:

Inauguration of the conference
Charles Escobar, Juan, Luis Gonzalez, myself, Zero from Bolivia (who gave me these photographs), Marco and a hacker from Bolivia (sorry, I forget his name)
That is me speaking, with the interpreter beside me
Serious discussion on how the Asuncion declaration should be worded, where Juan Carlos was the starSunday, April 25, 2010
Free Software Asuncion 2010
Being an invitee, they were supposed to send me my ticket to Asuncion. There was no sign of the ticket for a long time, and then my friend Juan asked me to go to Delhi and collect my visa, with the assurance that the ticket would reach me soon. So I reached Delhi on 18th night and my son picked me up. That night I was told that there was a mistake, I should go to the Consulate only on Tuesday because when they said Monday, what they had in mind was their Monday. Because of the nine and a half hour difference in time, that would be Tuesday in Delhi. I went to the Consulate on Tuesday and they were virtually waiting for me. Though I was now armed with the passport and ready to leave, the ticket still did not arrive. So my friend Juan suggested that I try for a ticket from India. That was when I too learnt about the problem the organisers also were facing -- the rush for travelling to Europe when flights resumed after being held up for several days due to the volcanic eruption in Iceland. But I was still able to find a seat via Mumbai-Dubai-Sao Paulo. But I decided to wait till the organisers confirmed that they would reimburse.
But meanwhile they were able to get hold of a ticket, also via Dubai-Sao Paulo and I received it on 21st evening. The ticket was for early morning of April 23, reaching Asuncion late night the same day because of the large time difference. The flight from Delhi was at 04:15 hr and the scheduled arrival in Asuncion was at 23:05 hr, which means a total travel duration of almost 28 hr 20 minutes! This was going to be the longest (distance-wise) journey I have ever in my life time!
I decided to carry as little luggage as possible and to confine it to cabin baggage. My son and my friend Sundar were of the opinion that I should carry plenty of clothes, but I stubbornly stuck to my plan and carried only one luggage (that could be checked in if needed) and a laptop bag that contained only a couple of books in addition to my laptop and accessories. My son, Akshay, and our friend Balachandran dropped me at the airport. When I checked in, I was not sure how the luggage would go, but the man at the counter of Emirates allowed me to carry both the bags with me in the cabin. So that saved the time required to wait for my luggage and reduced the tension about possible loss of luggage.
We had reached the Delhi airport around 01:30 hr on 23rd and the flight took off on time. Then there was a tough wait at Dubai airport for about four hours. I found a seat and started reading a book. It was tough to read the book on the one hand and keep awake on the other. But I somehow managed it because I had slept euring the day time and throughout the flight (except when the served the food). The flight from Dubai to Sao Paulo was the toughest part, lasting some 16 hours. I allowed myself to fall asleep whenever possible, but I needed to keep moving my feet so that they did not swell due to the long periods of being seated. I could not bring myself to watch the television programmes being dished out either. It was a truly challenging period, but finally we landed at Sao Paulo.
The wait at Sao Paulo was shorter, about three hours, and that period passed off relatively quickly. The flight from Sao Paulo to Asuncion was operated by TAM, an airlines from Paraguay. While both the flights from Delhi to Dubai and Dubai to Sao Paulo were operated by Emirates, and used huge Boeing 777-200 aircraft, the one to Asuncion was a smaller aircraft, possibly 747. And there were very few passengers. there was just one more passenger in the row in which I was sitting near the window. The flight was short, about two hours, and we soon landed.
As I came out of the aircraft and entered the airport building, I saw a person waiting with my name printed in large characters. I approached him and nodded to indicate that I was the person. Then things happened very quickly. I was taken through a special route (I thought it was the diplomatic channel) and seated in a luxurious lounge. A lady came there and collected my passport and customs declaration forms. Before I could use the toilet and sit down properly, she was back saying that everything was okay and I could leave. The gentleman who received me found a guy who was waiting for me with a car and I was soon moving towards the hotel where I am still put up and where the conference was held. This was an astonishing experience for me! I was being treated almost like a state guest!
The way passengers were treated in Dubai airport, I thought, left much to be desired. The officials there almost treated the passengers like cattle, though their language was always decent. Their body language showed what they thought, and occasionally they were rude to non-white passengers. I would have thought that their natural allies should be countries like India. Things were much better in Sao Paulo and some officials were really helpful. In the hotel, the counter clerk showed surprise when I told him that I was from India. I must be one of the very few Indians who have come to this hotel, and maybe even this country!
(About the conference itself, I should be soon writing in space blog, with photographs. See http://spacetvm.blogspot.com/)
Monday, April 19, 2010
Free Software Conference at Asuncion, Paraguay
I am supposed to speak on the Kerala experience, mainly the experience of the IT@School project. Arun of FSF India was also scheduled to go, but he backed out when things got unduly delayed. His case is different from mine because he is doing his MPhil now and cannot be away for long. In my case, I have been told that I may get to participate in other conferences and discussions. So I may have to stay for a couple of weeks or longer.
I am basically not very fond of travelling, so I am not really looking forward to the journey. One thing that I would enjoy is to visit some of the sites of ancient civilisations like the Mayans. I don't know whether I will be able to do that. But if I do, I shall write about it here. Got the visa. Waiting for the ticket now.
Tuesday, April 06, 2010
ഡോക്യുമെന്റ് സ്വാതന്ത്ര്യ ദിനം
മാര്ച്ച് 31 ഡോക്യുമെന്റ് സ്വാതന്ത്ര്യ ദിനമായി ആചരിക്കുകയാണു്. എന്താണീ ഡോക്യുമെന്റ് സ്വാതന്ത്ര്യം, എന്താണതിന്റെ പ്രാധാന്യം തുടങ്ങിയ കാര്യങ്ങള് നമുക്കിവിടെ പരിശോധിക്കാം.
പണ്ടുകാലത്തു് കേരളത്തിലെ ഔദ്യോഗിക രേഖകളെല്ലാം മലയാളത്തിലായിരുന്നല്ലോ. കടലാസു് ഉപയോഗിച്ചു് തുടങ്ങുന്നതിനു് മുമ്പു് ഓലയില് നാരായം ഉപയോഗിച്ചു് എഴുതിയിരുന്നു. അക്കാലത്തു് ഉപയോഗിച്ചിരുന്ന അക്ഷരങ്ങള് പലതും ഇന്നെഴുതുന്ന രീതിയിലായിരുന്നില്ല. പിന്നീടു് കടലാസും മഷിയും ഉപയോഗിച്ചു തുടങ്ങി. അക്കാലത്തെ രേഖകള് കടലാസില് ആയതുകൊണ്ടു തന്നെ ഓലയിലെഴുതിയ രേഖകള് പോലെ വളരെക്കാലം നില നില്ക്കുന്നതല്ലായിരുന്നു. മാത്രമല്ല മഷികൊണ്ടു് എഴുതിയതു് ക്രമേണ മാഞ്ഞു പോകുകയും ചെയ്യും. ടൈപ്പ് റൈറ്റര് എന്ന യന്ത്രം വന്നതോടുകൂടി ഈ പ്രശ്നത്തിനു് ഒരല്പം ആശ്വാസമായി. എന്നാല് ടൈപ്പ് ചെയ്തെടുക്കുന്ന രേഖകളിലെ വാക്കുകള് വായിക്കുന്നതു് ബുദ്ധിമുട്ടായിരുന്നു. കാരണം മലയാളത്തിലെ എല്ലാ അക്ഷരരൂപങ്ങളും ടൈപ്പ് റൈറ്ററില് ലഭ്യമല്ലായിരുന്നു. ഈ പ്രശ്നം പരിഹരിക്കാനായി മലയാള ലിപിയില്ത്തന്നെ മാറ്റം വരുത്തുകയുണ്ടായി.
രേഖകളുണ്ടാക്കാനുള്ള ഏറ്റവും പുതിയ സാങ്കേതിക വിദ്യയാണു് കമ്പ്യൂട്ടര്. അമേരിക്കയിലാണു് ആധുനിക കമ്പ്യൂട്ടര് ഉത്ഭവിച്ചതു് എന്നതുകൊണ്ടു് ഇംഗ്ലിഷും അതുപോലത്തെ ലിപി ഉപയോഗിക്കുന്ന ചില യൂറോപ്യന് ഭാഷകളുമാണു് കമ്പ്യൂട്ടറില് തനതായി കൈകാര്യം ചെയ്യാന് കഴിഞ്ഞിരുന്നതു്. മലയാളമുള്പ്പെടെയുള്ള മറ്റനേകം ഭാഷകളില് രേഖകളുണ്ടാക്കുന്നതിനു് ഒരു വിദ്യ ഉപയോഗിച്ചിരുന്നു. അക്ഷരങ്ങള് പ്രദര്ശിപ്പിക്കുന്നതിനും മറ്റും കമ്പ്യൂട്ടര് ഉപയോഗിക്കുന്ന ഫോണ്ട് അഥവാ ലിപിസഞ്ചയത്തില് മലയാളം അകഷരങ്ങള് ഉപയോഗിക്കുക എന്നതായിരുന്നു വിദ്യ. അടിസ്ഥാനപരമായി കമ്പ്യൂട്ടര് കൈകാര്യം ചെയ്യുന്നതു് ഇംഗ്ലീഷ് ഭാഷ തന്നെയായിരുന്നു. അതുകൊണ്ടുതന്നെ ഇതിനു് പല പരിമിതികളുണ്ടു്. പിന്നീടു് ലോകത്തിലെ എല്ലാ ഭാഷകളും ഉള്ക്കൊള്ളാന് കഴിയുന്ന യൂണിക്കോഡ് എന്ന സംവിധാനം വന്നപ്പോഴാണു് മലയാളവും കമ്പ്യൂട്ടറില് തനതായി ഉപയോഗിക്കാനായതു്.
ഇന്നു് വലിയ ശതമാനം കമ്പ്യൂട്ടറുകളും ഉപയോഗിക്കുന്നതു് മൈക്രോസോഫ്റ്റ് കമ്പനിയുടെ വിന്ഡോസ് ഓപ്പറേറ്റിങ് സിസ്റ്റമാണു്. സര്ക്കാര് തലത്തില് തന്നെ സ്വതന്ത്ര സോഫ്റ്റ്വെയര് പ്രോത്സാഹിപ്പിക്കുന്ന കേരളത്തില് പോലും സ്ഥിതി ഏതാണ്ടു് അങ്ങനെ തന്നെയാണു്, മാറി വരുന്നുണ്ടെങ്കിലും. പ്രധാനമായി വാക്കുകളടങ്ങിയ രേഖകള്, അതായതു് ടെക്സ്റ്റ് ഡോക്യുമെന്റുകള്, ഉണ്ടാക്കാന് വിന്ഡോസില് ഉപയോഗിക്കുന്ന പ്രധാനപ്പെട്ട ആപ്ലിക്കേഷന് സോഫ്റ്റ്വെയറുകള് (പ്രയോഗങ്ങള്) എല്ലാം സ്വതന്ത്രമല്ലാത്തവയാണു്, കമ്പനികള് നിര്മ്മിച്ചു് കച്ചവടം ചെയ്യുന്നവയാണു്. അവയിലോരോന്നും അതില് നിര്മ്മിക്കുന്ന രേഖകള് കമ്പ്യൂട്ടറില് സൂക്ഷിക്കുന്നതു് (സേവ് ചെയ്യുന്നതു്) അതിന്റെ സ്വന്തം രീതിയിലാണു് \dash\ അതായതു് അതിന്റേതായ രഹസ്യ ഫോര്മാറ്റിലാണു്. ഇതു് അല്പം വിശദീകരിക്കാം.
കമ്പ്യൂട്ടറില് എല്ലാ വിവരങ്ങളും (പ്രോഗ്രാമുകളും രേഖകളും) സൂക്ഷിക്കുന്നതും കൈകാര്യം ചെയ്യുന്നതും രണ്ടക്ഷരമുള്ള ഒരു ഭാഷയിലാണല്ലോ. 0, 1 എന്നീ അക്കങ്ങളാണു് ഈ രണ്ടക്ഷരങ്ങളെ സൂചിപ്പിക്കാന് സാധാരണ ഉപയോഗിക്കാറുള്ളതു്. മനുഷ്യര്ക്കു് വായിക്കാനാവുന്ന ഭാഷയില്നിന്നു് കമ്പ്യൂട്ടറിനു് മനസിലാകുന്ന ഈ (ബൈനറി) ഭാഷയിലേക്കു് മാറ്റി എഴുതുമ്പോള് അതിനു് എന്തു് രീതി വേണമെങ്കിലും ഉപയോഗിക്കാം. ഇംഗ്ലീഷ് ഭാഷയിലെ അക്ഷരങ്ങള് മാത്രമാണു് സൂക്ഷിക്കേണ്ടതെങ്കില് അതിനു് സാധാരണ ഉപയോഗിക്കുന്നതു് ആസ്ക്കി (ASCII) എന്ന രീതിയാണു്. എല്ലാ ഭാഷകളും ഉപയോഗിക്കാനാകുന്ന രീതിയാണു് യൂണിക്കോഡ്. പല രേഖകളിലും അക്ഷരങ്ങള് കൂടാതെ കടലാസിന്റെ വലുപ്പം, അക്ഷരങ്ങളുടെ വലുപ്പം, വരികള് തമ്മിലുള്ള അകലം എന്നിങ്ങനെ പല വിവരങ്ങളും അധികമായി സൂക്ഷിക്കേണ്ടി വരും. ഇതിനായി പ്രത്യേക കോഡുകളും രേഖയോടൊപ്പം ഉണ്ടാവണം. ഇതെല്ലാം സൂക്ഷിക്കുന്ന രീതി തീരുമാനിക്കുന്നതു് രേഖയുണ്ടാക്കാന് ഉപയോഗിക്കുന്ന സോഫ്റ്റ്വെയറാണു്. സ്വതന്ത്രമല്ലാത്ത സോഫ്റ്റ്വെയറുകളുടെ കാര്യത്തില് ഇതു് നിര്ണ്ണയിക്കുന്നതു് സോഫ്റ്റ്വെയര് നിര്മ്മിച്ച കമ്പനിയാണു്. അതു് മിക്കപ്പോഴും രഹസ്യവുമാണു്.
മേല്പറഞ്ഞ കാര്യങ്ങളുടെ ഫലമായി സ്വതന്ത്രമല്ലാത്ത പ്രയോഗങ്ങളുപയോഗിച്ചു് നിര്മ്മിക്കുന്ന രേഖകള് കൃത്യമായി തുറന്നു കാണണമെങ്കില് അവ നിര്മ്മിക്കാനുപയോഗിച്ച പ്രയോഗങ്ങള് തന്നെ വേണമെന്നു വരുന്നു. ചിലപ്പോള് മറ്റു ചില പ്രയോഗങ്ങളിലും അവ തുറന്നു കാണാനായി എന്നു വരാം; പക്ഷെ അപ്പോള് നാം കാണുന്നതു് നിര്മ്മിച്ചയാള് ഉദ്ദേശിച്ച തരത്തില് തന്നെ ആവണമെന്നില്ല. ഉദാഹരണമായി, മൈക്രോസോഫ്റ്റ് വേഡ് എന്ന പ്രയോഗത്തില് നിര്മ്മിച്ച ഒരു രേഖ വേഡ് പെര്ഫെക്ട് എന്ന പ്രയോഗത്തില് തുറക്കാനായി എന്നു വരാം. പക്ഷെ രേഖ മാറ്റമൊന്നും കൂടാതെയാണു് കാണുന്നതു് എന്നു് ഉറപ്പാക്കാനാവില്ല. പലപ്പോഴും ഒരു പ്രയോഗത്തില് നിര്മ്മിച്ചതു് മറ്റൊന്നില് തുറക്കാനേ ആവില്ല. അങ്ങനെ വരുമ്പോള് നമ്മള് ഒരു കമ്പനിയുടെ സോഫ്റ്റ്വെയര് തന്നെ ഉപയോഗിക്കാന് നിര്ബ്ബന്ധിതരാകുന്നു. അതായതു്, നമ്മള് ആ കമ്പനിയുടെ ആശ്രിതരാകുന്നു.
എന്നാല് ഇങ്ങനെ ആവേണ്ട കാര്യമില്ല. അതിനു് രേഖകള് സൂക്ഷിക്കുന്ന രീതി തുറന്നതായാല് മതി. അതായതു്, രേഖകള് സൂക്ഷിക്കാനുപയോഗിക്കുന്ന രീതി എന്താണു് എന്നു് ആര്ക്കും മനസിലാക്കാനുള്ള മാര്ഗമുണ്ടായാല് മതി. ഇതു് മറ്റൊരു ഉദാഹരണം കൊണ്ടു് വിശദീകരിക്കാന് ശ്രമിക്കട്ടെ. ഒരു സൈന്യത്തിലെ ഉദ്യോഗസ്ഥര് പരസ്പരം സന്ദേശങ്ങളയക്കുമ്പോള്, വിശേഷിച്ചു് യുദ്ധകാലത്തു്, സാധാരണ ഭാഷയാവില്ല ഉപയോഗിക്കുന്നതു്. കാരണം ശത്രുസൈന്യത്തിനു് സന്ദേശം പിടിച്ചെടുക്കാനായാല് പോലും അവര്ക്കു് മനസിലാക്കാന് കഴിയരുതു്. അതിനു് ഒരു രഹസ്യ ഭാഷയാവും ഉപയോഗിക്കുക. ആ ഭാഷ അറിയാത്തവര്ക്കു് അതു് വായിക്കാനാവില്ലല്ലോ. അതുപോലെ ഒരു പ്രയോഗം അതുണ്ടാക്കുന്ന രേഖകള് സൂക്ഷിക്കാനുപയോഗിക്കുന്ന രീതി അറിയാതെ ആ രേഖകള് തുറക്കാനാകുന്ന മറ്റൊരു പ്രയോഗം (ആപ്ലിക്കേഷല്) നിര്മ്മിക്കാനും ആവില്ലല്ലോ. ആലോചിച്ചു നോക്കൂ, പണ്ടുകാലത്തു് സര്ക്കാര് രേഖകള് ഒരു രഹസ്യ ഭാഷയിലാണു് എഴുതിയിരുന്നതെങ്കില് ഇന്നവ നമുക്കു് വായിച്ചു മനസിലാക്കാന് ആവുമായിരുന്നില്ലല്ലോ.
രേഖകളെല്ലാം കമ്പ്യൂട്ടറില് നിര്മ്മിക്കുകയും സൂക്ഷിക്കുകയും ചെയ്യുന്ന ഇക്കാലത്തു് ഇതു് പ്രശ്നമാകാം. വളരെക്കാലം സൂക്ഷിക്കേണ്ട രേഖകള് നിര്മ്മിക്കുമ്പോള് സുതാര്യമായ രീതിയില് സൂക്ഷിച്ചില്ലെങ്കില് പിന്നീടു് അവ വായിക്കാനായി എന്നു വരില്ല. അതിനു് വഴിയുണ്ടു താനും. രേഖകള് സൂക്ഷിക്കാന് സുതാര്യമായ ഫോര്മാറ്റുകളുണ്ടു്. വെറും ആസ്ക്കി, അഡോബിന്റെ പോര്ട്ടബിള് ഡോക്യുമെന്റ് ഫോര്മാറ്റ് (പി.ഡി.എഫ്), മൈക്രോസോഫ്റ്റിന്റെ റിച്ച് ടെക്സ്റ്റ് ഫോര്മാറ്റ്, തുടങ്ങി പലതുമുണ്ടു്. എന്നാല് മാനദണ്ഡങ്ങള് സൂക്ഷിക്കുന്ന സാര്വ്വദേശീയ സംഘടന (International Standards Organisation, ISO) അംഗീകരിച്ച തുറന്നതും സ്വതന്ത്രവുമായ മാനദണ്ഡമാണു് ഓപ്പണ് ഡോക്യുമെന്റ് ഫോര്മാറ്റ് (ODF). ഈ രീതിയില് രേഖകള് സൂക്ഷിക്കുന്ന ഒരു പ്രയോഗമാണു് സ്വതന്ത്ര സോഫ്റ്റ്വെയറായ ഓപ്പണ് ഓഫീസ്. എന്നാല് സുതാര്യമായതിനാല് ഈ രീതിയില് രേഖകള് സൂക്ഷിക്കാനും അത്തരം രേഖകള് കൃത്യമായി തുറക്കാനും കഴിയുന്ന പ്രയോഗങ്ങള് ആര്ക്കും നിര്മ്മിക്കാവുന്നതാണു്. ഇത്തരം സുതാര്യതയാണു് ഇന്റര്നെറ്റ് വഴി ആശയങ്ങള് കൈമാറുന്നതു് സാധ്യമാക്കിയതു് എന്നോര്ക്കുക. വെബ് പേജുകളിലിടുന്ന വിവരങ്ങള് രഹസ്യ ഫോര്മാറ്റുകളിലായിരുന്നു എങ്കില് എത്രയോ കുറച്ചു പേര്ക്കു മാത്രമെ ഇന്റര്നെറ്റിലെ വിവരങ്ങള് ഉപയോഗിക്കാന് കഴിയുമായിരുന്നുള്ളൂ!
മുകളില് സൂചിപ്പിച്ചതുപോലെ സര്ക്കാര് രേഖകളുടെ കാര്യത്തില് ഈ സുതാര്യത അത്യാവശ്യമാണു്, വിശേഷിച്ചു് സര്ക്കാരുകളുടെ നടത്തിപ്പിലും പൊതുജനവുമായുള്ള ഇടപാടുകളിലും വര്ദ്ധിച്ചുവരുന്ന തോതില് കമ്പ്യൂട്ടര് ഉപയോഗിച്ചു വരുന്ന ഇക്കാലത്തു്. ഇന്നുണ്ടാക്കുന്ന രേഖകള് പത്തോ ഇരുപതോ അമ്പതോ വര്ഷത്തിനു ശേഷവും തുറന്നു കാണാന് കഴിയണം എന്നതു് നിര്ബ്ബന്ധമാണു്. ഒരു കമ്പനിയുടെ നിയന്ത്രണത്തിലുള്ള ഫോര്മാറ്റിലാണു് രേഖകള് സൂക്ഷിക്കുന്നതെങ്കില് ഇതു് സാധ്യമാവണമെന്നില്ല. നമുക്കാവശ്യം വരുമ്പോള് ആ കമ്പനി ഉണ്ടാവണമെന്നില്ല. ഉണ്ടെങ്കില് തന്നെ അന്നത്തെ ആഗോള രാഷ്ട്രീയത്തിന്റെ പശ്ചാത്തലത്തില് അവര് നമ്മോടു് സഹകരിക്കണമെന്നുമില്ല. എന്തായാലും ഏതോ ഒരു കമ്പനിയുടെ നിയന്ത്രണത്തിലാവരുതല്ലോ നമ്മുടെ പ്രധാനപ്പെട്ട രേഖകള്.
രേഖകളുടെ സ്വാതന്ത്ര്യം എന്ന ആശയം പ്രചരിപ്പിക്കുന്നതിനാണു് ഡോക്യുമെന്റ് സ്വാതന്ത്ര്യ ദിനം ആചരിക്കുന്നതു്. ഇന്ത്യയില് ഇപ്പോള് ഇതിനു് വിശേഷിച്ചൊരു പ്രസക്തിയുണ്ടു്. ഇ ഗവേണന്സിനു് ഉപയോഗിക്കേണ്ട മാനദണ്ഡങ്ങള് നിര്ണ്ണയിക്കുന്ന നയം കേന്ദ്ര സര്ക്കാര് രൂപീകരിച്ചു \mbox{വരികയാണു്.} തുറന്ന, സുതാര്യമായ, ഫോര്മാറ്റുകള് മാത്രം ഉപയോഗിച്ചാല് മതി എന്നതായിരുന്നു നയത്തിന്റെ കരടുരേഖയില് അടുത്ത കാലം വരെ പറഞ്ഞിരുന്നതു്. വിദഗ്ദ്ധരും പൊതുജന സംഘടനകളും മറ്റുമായി ചര്ച്ച നടത്തിയായിരുന്നു അതു് തീരുമാനിച്ചിരുന്നതു്. എന്നാല് ഇപ്പോള് അതില് മാറ്റം വന്നതായി കാണുന്നു. ഉടമസ്ഥാവകാശമുള്ള രഹസ്യമായ ഫോര്മാറ്റുകളും ആവാം എന്നായിരിക്കുന്നു ഇപ്പോഴത്തെ നിലപാടു്. ഇതു് ദീര്ഘകാലത്തെ കാഴ്ചപ്പാടില് നമ്മുടെ രാജ്യത്തിനു് തീര്ച്ചയായും നല്ലതല്ല. രഹസ്യമായി കൊണ്ടുവന്ന ഈ മാറ്റം ഉപേക്ഷിക്കാന് സര്ക്കാരില് സമ്മര്ദ്ദം ചെലുത്തേണ്ടതു് അത്യാവശ്യമാണു്.
Thursday, February 25, 2010
Adopt Free and Open Standards for Digital Documents
The same is true in the case of the ubiquitous modern device, the computer. The keyboard is the same on all of them, the compact disks we use are of the same size and we need not relearn the use of a keyboard when we buy a new computer, nor do we have to specify a certain size for the CD we buy. These are all examples of open standards that have been adopted by the industry. And these standards make our life easier because we need not unduly worry about what we buy. However, that is not necessarily the case with what we use in the computer.
Society has started using the computer for all kinds of purposes, including creating documents, pictures, animations, videos, databases and so on. These are stored in a manner that only a computer can decipher. This happens transparently so that even computer users may not realise how they are stored. For instance, when I type this article, it is stored in the computer in the form of what we call a “file”. A file is a collection of ones and zeroes stored electronically. Each character in a text document like this one or each tiny bit of colour in a picture is represented in a computer by a group of ones and zeroes. What set of ones and zeroes represent a character is decided by the method of encoding used for creating the file. For many purposes, the rule by which this conversion is made is open to the public – such as ASCII or Unicode. But certain applications, such as Microsoft Word, save files it creates in a manner that is not open. It writes files into hard disks in a purely “binary” format that consists of ones and zeroes in an order that is determined by a rule that is known only to the makers of Word. In other words, that file can be opened and the original document seen in the proper manner only if Microsoft Word is used. Of course, some other people have worked out the manner in which Word does it, but not perfectly. Therefore, the file could be opened, albeit imperfectly, using some other applications also. This is the case not only with Microsoft Word, but is true of all proprietary applications including Adobe Photoshop, Lotus 123 and CorelDraw. Of course, this is the default behaviour and each of these is capable of saving the files in other formats (which, again, may not be perfect).
But that is certainly not an ideal situation. What it means is that we users become dependent on the software that we use to create our documents to open them. That means, if we want to open a document created using Microsoft Word, and see it in the way we had made it, we will have to use Microsoft Word itself. The problem is that we don't know what a later version of the application will support. There is no guarantee that a file created with an earlier version will be cleanly opened by a new version of the same software. More importantly, in today's dog eats dog world, there is no guarantee that even the company wll exist a few years hence. And this is not mere speculation. WordPerfect used to be the most popular word processor some years back. But very few people use it today, even though it is probably the best word processor ever according to many people. WordPerfect was purchased by Corel, which itself is a struggling company. It could be wound up any day, and WordPerfect may no longer be available. And no other application today can cleanly open documents created with WordPerfect.
Such a situation is bad enough for private documents. Imagine the situation in which important documents related to the matters of a country are stored in formats created by proprietary software companies – formats that are not open and therefore inaccessible to anyone other than those who created the software. It could become very difficult to retrieve the information. Or critical information about citizens of a country. The risk is not only of the information getting locked in, but also of a software company potentially holding a country to ransom. It may be appropriate to narrate an incident in this connection.
Venezuela is a poor country that is very much dependent on its oil resources. Petróleos de Venezuela S.A. (PDVSA), often pronounced Pedevesa, is a state-owned company that runs the oil industry there. A whole lot of processes, including metering, invoicing, billing, and customer service, was handled by proprietary software. At a particular point in the political transformation that happened in Venezuela, a large number of employees who were managing the computer system resigned and left suddenly, and took the user manuals with them (it seems under instigation from external sources that wanted to create trouble for the new regime). Not only was the whole system left without anyone to manage, the entire data, in a format designed by the company making it inaccessible to others. The company, conveniently, refused to help the country. The entire economy of the country was on the brink of collapse. It was saved only because a group of young people managed to migrate the entire computer system to Free Software – software that would save all information in a format that is open, ensuring that it will always be accessible.
Obviously, governments should ensure that all their data are stored in open formats so that at no time will they held to ransom by agencies, external or internal, that wished to create trouble for them. Use of standards is a requirement for a technological society. The standards for the units of measurement were an important step in the history of mankind. The possibility of interoperability of equipment such as telephones, radios or televisions, among others, is based on common standards of operation. The only way to ensure that everyone can build appliances, equipment or software that interact with each other is the use of open standards. This enables the storage and exchange of information and data between individuals or groups in different places and times.
There seems to exist an argument that proprietary standards should be allowed to co-exist with free and open standards. But this is meaningless, since there can be only one standard for one purpose. Else, it ceases to be a standard. Imagine having the metre and the fathom as "standards". While the former is a measure of length that is defined as precisely as humanly possible, the other is a rough measure based on the distance between the fingertips of an average individual's hands. Let us forget this aspect for the moment, and imagine that the fathom is another standard. What could happen is that some people could specify lengths in terms of the metre, and others could use the fathom. People would have to go on converting from one system to the other. Of course, this may contribute to improving the computing skills of individuals, but it could contribute much more to confusion. Remember the times we used to get bolts, nuts and screws in both the Imperial and the metric standards. Many unwary people landed up purchasing bolts that would not fit the nuts and screws that wouldn't go into threaded holes that were meant for them.
In any case, it is not good for government documents that will have to be maintained for a number of years. Problems could be especially severe if the "standard" adopted is not Free and Open and is proprietary. In the case of Free and open standards, even if the application that created the documents ceased to exist, the government could hire someone to create an application to open the document, since the format is open. Documents that are encoded in proprietary formats, such as the .doc format of MS Word or the .pm format of Adobe Pagemaker, would make it extremely difficult to open if the original application ceases to exist. Even if it did not, the government would become dependent on that company for ever. It is for such reasons that Free Software activists and others who understand the trap have been saying that the formats used by the governments for storing documents should be free and open.
But the latest draft document on formats to be used for e-governance speaks about other formats co-existing with free and open formats, which it had not till the previous draft. Why this change was made is totally unclear. Till the previous version, the draft was prepared after extensive consultations with the industry and the community, making it rather transparent. But the latest draft was prepared by someone (a bureaucrat?) under the strong influence of one or more company executives. The government seems to have placed the interests of the companies before those of the nation and the people. I would like to join a number of people including Free Software enthusiasts to urge the government to drop this move and admit only the use of Free and Open formats for documents of the government.
Saturday, October 17, 2009
Beware of Microsoft!
But here is another threat now. Apparently, Microsoft released a patch some time back that has made the browser Firefox risky to use. Of course, it made their own Internet Explorer also risky, but that has always had plenty of security holes, so one more was not a big thing. Firefox is considered to be more secure even on Windoze, but apparently Microsoft's patch has made it vulnerable to attacks. You don't have to take my word for it, you can read the story in Computer World. It says, "An add-on that Microsoft silently slipped into Mozilla's Firefox last February leaves the browser open to attack, Microsoft's security engineers acknowledged earlier this week." We should thank Microsoft for acknowedging the fact.
Apparently, the plug-in could be installed without the knowledge of the user. And once installed, it was not at all easy to remove it. The usual "Disable" button seen for each plug-in would itself be disabled. And one had to wade through the Windows Registry (which is a risky thing to do and not recommended for normal users to do) to remove the plug-in. It is unclear whether this happened unwittingly or whether it was a deliberate move on the part of Microsoft to put a brake on the steady increase in popularity that Firefox has been showing at the expense of Internet Explorer. I would have thought that the former could be true, though I wouldn't put the latter beyond Microsoft, but for one reason: that Microsoft has done things that many businessmen would never think of, and are possibly continuing to do such things too.
Let me tell you one such thing that they are probably doing. I was told that the Google desktop search tool is locked in Windows Vista. I have to admit that I have not tested this myself, since I really don't have a machine with Vista anywhere near me. It apparently requires the Windows key to be unlocked. Well, this could be a bug somewhere, but again, it could be deliberate too. MS certainly wouldn't want a Google software to become popular on their systems especially when they are in direct competition in the Net search area. Not that Bing is popular - certainly not anywhere near Google.
Another thing I was told is that Firefox runs slow on Windows. Well, as I said earlier, it could be accidental, or it could be deliberate. But with Microsoft, I would put my bet on the latter. As someone once told me, it is not that Microsoft engineers are fools. If they make it all very nice and perfect the first time itself, what will be the attraction in new versions? And where will be the antivirus business - something that Microsoft itself is planning to do?
Monday, August 03, 2009
Dreaming of a peer to peer world
The economic collapse of 2008 is leading many people to question the suitability of the capitalist economic system. At the same time, many people are unsure about the system that can replace capitalism. The most common solution is, of course, socialism. But there are those who wonder whether there could be alternatives, though no serious discussion seems to have taken place on this subject. No one today sincerely expects an armed revolution. On the one hand, there appears to be a serious revival of interest in Marxism in Europe and even in the United States, while on the other hand there are people who are being inspired by the success of movements like Free Software and Wikipedia which point to aspects of creativity and production that we have ignored for too long or misinterpreted deliberately or otherwise.
We now know that creativity can and does happen without any incentive, especially financial incentive. And sometimes even without recognition. A brief reflection should convince anyone that creativity happens naturally, not because of financial incentives. In fact, it is clear that financial incentives cannot be the reason for creativity -- an idea that directly contradicts the concepts behind copyright and patents.
Free Software exists because there are people who enjoy creating software and who are willing to share it with others. Contributors are recognised by the community. On the other hand, the thousands of people who contributed to the more than 2.5 million articles in English, and smaller numbers in more than 250 other languages in Wikipedia, do not even get credit for their contributions. They remain anonymous forever. Yet, millions of articles have been written. Similarly, millions of people voluntarily contribute their computer time to computation-intensive projects like SETI@Home.
These are examples of a modern phenomenon that defies explanation within the existing paradigm -- a true revolution, in the Kuhnian sense, waiting for a paradigm shift. Many modern thinkers recognise that it forces us to reconsider our notions about production and distribution of goods. “Without a broadly accepted analytic model to explain these phenomena, we tend to treat them as curiosities, perhaps transient fads…” says Yochai Benkler in his The Wealth of Networks. But these do not appear to be curiosities or fads but symptoms of a genuine change in the way we think, create and distribute goods.
And this is prompting people to enquire into the possibilities of emulating that model in the production of ‘real’ goods (as opposed to ‘virtual' goods like software and knowledge). They also believe they can avoid the alienation of worker from work that Karl Marx warned about, just as in the case of Free Software and Wikipedia.
Michel Bauwens is one of those who believe in open spaces and creation without incentive. Like Richard Stallman who left his prestigious job at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology and started the Free Software Foundation, Michel also left a remunerative corporate job to start the Peer to Peer Foundation that tries to study the evolving peer to peer production and distribution systems exemplified by Free Software and Wikipedia. Michel Bauwens was in Thiruvananthapuram, Kerala, in December 2008, to participate in the Free Software Free Society conference and talked about the work of the Foundation. In this interview, done through email after his return to Thailand, Michel speaks about how he decided to leave his job and start the P2P Foundation, what principles the Foundation is based on, what its work is, and how the work has been progressing.You were an information scientist and magazine editor before you started the P2P Foundation. Can you tell us about this evolution? How did it happen?
My first job (but without any formal library and information science training, as I studied political science) was nine years as reference librarian and information analyst for a centre in Brussels. In 1990, I started working as strategic business information manager at the headquarters of the agribusiness wing of British Petroleum. At that time, I reformulated the role of librarian into that of ‘cybrarian’, ie managing “just in time, just for you” information streams to senior management who were not in any real sense using the physical library resources anymore.
As the animal feed businesses were divested by 1993, I moved on to creating a Flemish magazine that was a mix of Mondo 2000 and Wired, and then became one of the Internet evangelists in my home country, leading to work as a serial Internet entrepreneur.
From my very first encounter with the Internet, ie collective mailing lists combining experts from around the world, I knew this was a technology that would change the very fabric of our world. Never before had there been such real-time possibilities for human cooperation and collective intelligence on a global scale. From now on, the privileged communication infrastructures that were only in the hands of multinationals and the State, would be distributed and democratised, a shift at least as important as the effect of the printing press.
At the same time, I became increasingly dissatisfied with the corporate world, seeing how the neoliberal system not only created increased social inequality, exacted a terrible psychic cost from even its privileged managerial layers, while also creating havoc in our natural world. I started seeing the system as a giant Ponzi scheme (a scheme in which the profit of those who invest earlier comes from those who invest later), so what surprised me was not the meltdown of 2008, but why it took so long to actually manifest itself!
At the same time, there was a revival of social resistance starting in 1995, and I was noticing, as a professional trend-watcher, that there was a common template in the new forms of social organisation, the one I now call the ‘peer to peer’ dynamic, or ‘voluntary permissionless self-aggregation around the production of common value’.
Key for me was the observation of the Internet bust in April 2000, which I witnessed from a privileged position as I was working in the same sector. As the stock market imploded, pundits were predicting the end of the Internet because no more capital was available for innovation and development. In fact the opposite happened -- rather than diminishing, innovation increased, entirely driven by the social field of aggregating geeks, giving birth to the Web 2.0, the first social model based on an interrelationship between new forms of capitalism and user-generated production of value. I knew then that I would study this phenomenon more deeply, and in particular since I consider peer aggregation to be a non-alienating form of work, how it could be leveraged as a force for social change.
So in October 2002, I decided to quit my corporate engagement, take a sabbatical to think things through, and moved to Thailand to create a global cyber-collective to research and promote P2P dynamics.
Is there a basic set of hypotheses from which the Foundation starts?
Yes, I formulated the following principles when I started the Foundation:
- That peer to peer-based technology reflects a change of consciousness towards participation, and in turn, strengthens it.
- That the ‘distributed network’ format, expressed in the specific manner of peer to peer relations, is a new form of political organising and subjectivity, and an alternative for the current political/economic order, ie I believe that peer to peer allows for ‘permission-less’ self-organisation to create common value, in a way that is more productive than both the state and private for-profit alternatives. People can now engage in peer production that creates very complex ‘products’ that can achieve higher quality standards than pure corporate competitors.
I also believe that it creates a new public domain, an information commons, which should be protected and extended, especially in the domain of common knowledge-creation; and that this domain, where the cost of reproducing knowledge is near-zero, requires fundamental changes in the intellectual property regime, as reflected by new forms such as the free software movement; that universal common property regimes, ie modes of peer property such as the general public licence and the creative commons licences should be promoted and extended.
These principles developed by the free software movement, in particular the general public licence, and the general principles behind the open source and open access movements, provide for models that could be used in other areas of social and productive life.
If we can connect this new mode of production, pioneered by knowledge workers, with the older traditions of sharing and solidarity of workers and farmers movements, then we can build a very strong contemporary social movement that can transcend the failures of socialism.
I think it also offers youth a vision of renewal and hope, to create a world that is more in tune with their values.
I call the new peer to peer mode a ‘total social fact’, because it integratively combines subjectivity (new values), inter-subjectivity (new relations), objectivity (an enabling technology) and inter-objectivity (new forms of organisation) that mutually strengthen each other in a positive feedback loop, and it is clearly on the offensive and growing, but lacking ‘political self-consciousness’. It is this form of awareness that the P2P Foundation wants to promote.
Was this mostly your work, or were others involved in formulating these principles?
I formulated the principles on my own, but also after at least two years of reading, and of being attuned with the zeitgeist (zeitgeist describes the intellectual, cultural, ethical and political climate, ambience and morals of an era). Others were formulating similar ideas, though in different ways. So as usual we should not claim too much personal merit; we are standing on the shoulders of the giants of the past, and are simply lucky to accompany a deep shift in human consciousness that would be taking place without us just as well. At the most, we can try to put some extra grease in the machine.
What exactly does the Foundation do?
We want to be an interconnecting platform for people involved in realising the new open and free, participatory and commons-oriented paradigms in every social field. So, we are monitoring and describing real-world initiatives, theoretical efforts, creating a library of primary and secondary material, and trying to make sense of that aggregation by developing a coherent set of concepts and principles. We do this with a wiki, with nearly 8,000 pages of information, which have been viewed over 5 million times; through a blog reaching about 35,000 unique users last year, a Ning community with a few hundred members, and a number of mailing lists. The most active is the peer to peer research list, where academics and non-academics can collaboratively reach understandings. We also had two annual physical meet-ups in Belgium and the UK, and have some national groups such as in the Netherlands and Greece. There’s a lot of hidden activity acting as connectors between various initiatives, which, despite the global Internet, often don’t know they are working on very similar projects that could reinforce each other.
Peer to peer happens without us, but we want to add a little interconnecting grease to the system. My ultimate aim is to create a powerful social movement that can support the necessary reforms for social justice, sustainability of the natural world, and opening up science and culture to open and free sharing and collaboration, so that the whole weight of the collective intelligence of humanity can be brought to bear on the grave challenges we are facing.
How do you see the work that has already been done? Is it progressing according to your expectations?
I’m pleased on some levels, frustrated at others. In three years, we have constructed a sizeable amount of interrelated information and knowledge, and a ‘community of understanding’. I think we have a ‘really existing virtual community’ that cares about the ideals that we formulated. Each of these people are themselves active in their own real-world projects, some of which will be crucial change agents in the near future. Undoubtedly, the P2P Foundation is a global brand at least on the level of Internet users, as we have not crossed the boundary to mass media reporting. Our growth seems slow, but organic and rather strong, with not so much turnover and a lot of loyalty. Our internal culture of civil discourse seems very strong. On a personal level, I have a little more social and reputational capital, and have been privileged to explain P2P in several countries on four continents, which has allowed me to relate physical presence with the virtual network -- a strong combination.
My big frustration is that I failed to develop a ‘business model’ to sustain myself and my family, so I’m returning to paid employment in a few weeks, which will necessarily diminish my engagement, which has been full-time for the last three years, with the P2P Foundation’s work.
Do you see a P2P society as the state into which a society should evolve naturally? Something like how capitalist society evolved from feudal society?
If we look at the transition from slavery to feudalism, and from feudalism to capitalism, I think we discover a similar pattern. An old system in crisis and decline, the birth of more productive methods of creating value, and both sections of the ruling class and of the ‘producing’ class morphing to adapt to the new possibilities. Before feudalism and capitalism became disruptive to the old orders that they replaced they actually were used to strengthen the old order, and stave off their decline, because they were better ways of organising production and social relationships. So, today, hyper-productive peer to peer dynamics are being born in a mutually dependent relationship with capitalism, but ultimately slated to replace it. But first it needs to grow from seed form to parity form -- think of the situation in Rome between the 5th and 10th century, or 18th century European capitalism existing within the still-dominant remnants of the late feudal order of the ancient regime. Today, we see knowledge and other workers increasingly adopting modes of peer production, and netarchical capitalists such as Google and YouTube enabling and empowering sharing platforms, while extracting value from the value engendered through that social cooperation. All these processes take time, but that does not mean that they are necessarily smooth. The more established interests try to stop more productive alternatives, the more tension they create in the social system, the more this will express itself in crisis form. Both the birth of feudalism and capitalism were rather harsh transitions. This time we may hope that the global crisis of the biosphere, and the speed of innovation through global networks will speed up the process of change significantly.
I sometimes use the concept of ‘conditional inevitability’ to name this state of affairs in which a form of change is both necessary and likely, but can still be derailed because it depends on human agency and social struggle and creativity.
The alienation of work from the worker is one of the important aspects that Karl Marx has written about. The peer to peer system that you are trying to develop theoretically appears to tackle this issue. Have discussions at the P2P Foundation taken this aspect into consideration specifically?
Peer to peer is a form of what Alan Page Fiske calls communal shareholding in which each freely contributes to a common that is universally available to those who may need it. Because it is based on a passion-based free engagement and allows the producers to be autonomous and in charge of their own production process, it is in fact already a non-alienated form of work. It allows for the free self-unfolding of the individual, for autonomy-in-interdependence! It corresponds to what Marx called communism, the final stage of his future history, which was to be preceded by socialism, where each would get according to his contribution. The irony is that this mode of commonism is already being born within capitalism itself, creating a post-monetary seed within it. The important question is whether this seed form, now combined with capitalism, could also be combined with some form of socialism in the world of physical material production. My answer is yes, it is possible, but I prefer to leave this question open and to combine peer to peer as the core process for immaterial production and social innovation, with a pluralist economy for dealing with physical production, where individuals can choose whether they want to follow market-based exchange forms, or any other. The issue for me is not the market, but only capitalism as an infinite growth form and therefore a cancer for the biosphere and humanity. Capitalism will pass (if not, it would destroy us, and I don’t believe humanity will allow this to happen), but we may want to keep the market.
The important thing is to be non-coercive about it. As Eben Moglen said: ‘Free software’ (and thus peer production) is the wet dream of both capitalists and communists. What he means I think is that we can marry the strivings for freedom of liberalism with the strivings for equality of the left in a way in which both are not just mutually compatible but dependent on each other.
Have you thought about the system of governance that could be suitable for a P2P society? Would it be more akin to that in a capitalist society or to that in a socialist society -- you know, multi-party versus single party with a kind of democratic centrism?
I think we have to recognise different levels. The reality of peer governance is already well-known from the experience of Free Software communities, and we must insist that it is non-representational and avoids conflicts over the allocation of resources through coordinated self-allocation. But this can only fully work in the immaterial world. Note how Free Software and open design communities distinguish between the self-aggregation of voluntary work, and on the NGOs that are in charge of the scarcity-driven infrastructure of cooperation, which use democratic procedures. In society as a whole therefore, and though that part may shrink as we design and engineer more abundance, we still need democracy, though perhaps in a much more diversified way than today. So imagine a level of pure peer governance in the open production communities, representative democracy, and hybrid formats in between. In any case, in our complexifying society, we have to expect a significant increase of participatory processes. This democracy should be as far removed from capitalist pressure as it is from totalitarian centralised planning, but I imagine that we’ll have much more global coordination of resource flows, and not just market mechanisms.
How do you see the present global meltdown? Is it one of the crises that capitalist society faces once in a while? Or do you think it could possibly be the beginning of the decline of capitalism?
I tend to trust the analysis in terms of Kondratieff cycles as expressed by Carlota Perez in her work on technological revolutions (http://www.carlotaperez.org/). The last one started with World War II and was ascendant into the early-’70s, after which the declining phase of neoliberalism took over choosing the speculative route that now collapsed. We’ll need seven or 10 years to go through a severe cleaning out, but after a period of reform, such as perhaps that carried out by Obama in the next few years, we can expect a new up-cycle based on green capitalism, and extensive usage of participatory processes. This will allow P2P processes to move from the margins to the parity level. There is no chance of achieving sustainability without changing individual lifestyles and participatory design.
After this, we’ll reach the national crisis stage of the next Kondratieff cycle, and I believe this is the moment when the peer to peer logic can become dominant. In the end, the infinite growth mechanism of capitalism is incompatible with our finite natural environment, and necessarily needs to be replaced.
Do you believe that capitalism has to grow and mature before a society can change to P2P or something similar?
I think that capitalism is already beyond maturity and has reached senility, but there’s still life in the old man. So I see the green capitalist global compact as the last attempt at integration, and though it will have some success, it is clear that a system based on infinite growth is doomed. What we have to do imperatively is separate the idea of markets and trading from the idea of infinite growth. Some people are talking about natural capitalism (David Korten, Paul Hawken, Hazel Henderson) or capitalism 3.0 (Peter Barnes) to indicate the hybrid nature of the potential new system, which will combine markets with participation and peer to peer-based social innovation. But the concept is misleading, as the system cannot possibly be based on capital accumulation. I think Umair Haque is also a good guide as to the logic of the new post-capitalist system.
What is your personal opinion?
As indicated in the germ form theory of Oekonux, with which I broadly agree, first we have an emerging germ form -- the situation today. Then, it may evolve to a parity level, in which peer to peer and the market will co-exist. But at some point, the meta-system of infinite growth that is capitalism will and must break down if we want humanity and our planet to survive, and at that moment the old meta-system of capitalism will become a sub-system, a market form for certain specific rival goods within the broader meta-system of peer to peer. But humanity always first tries the familiar solutions, so before thinking of a more radical overhaul, a green capitalist phase is unavoidable but also necessary in order to allow participation to reach a parity level. To answer specifically concerning ‘natural capitalism’: to the degree that we succeed in forcing the market to integrate the external cost of natural destruction, and to fund its dependence on social innovation, to that degree the infinite growth mechanism will be broken and what we’ll have will be a market form but no longer a ‘capitalist’ one.
How do you think, in a situation like that in India where feudalism has still not disappeared and capitalism is growing, the ideas of P2P will work?
I think we have to think in terms of neo-traditional economics and policies. This means understanding the commonality between pre-materialist and post-materialist logics, seeing that both are united through the priority given to immaterial wellbeing. On the basis of the generalised crisis of capitalism, local resilient communities and the local elite can both look to leapfrogging possibilities, using high technology, but in a re-localised framework. For example, we can imagine local elite families investing in production facilities for smart cars using renewable energy, but allied with global open design and tinkering communities; and we can imagine farmer movements linking up with brothers and sisters worldwide in order to exchange practical knowledge and experience in order to avoid taking the route of soil-destroying industrial agriculture. There are many possibilities, if the awareness is there to profit from them.
(This article is published under the Creative Commons Attribution No Derivatives licence. This article may be reproduced in any media provided this note is also included. Details of the licence are available at http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nd/2.5/in)
This article appeared in Infochange India (http://infochangeindia.org/200907137829/Technology/Features/Dreaming-of-a-peer-to-peer-world.html) and also in the July 2009 issue of the magazine Agenda published by the same organisation.
